Skip to main content

User account menu

  • Log in
Shopping cart 0
Cart

Search

Search
Home The Northside Sun
  • Post
    • Leaderboard
    • Post Dashboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our History
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
    • Wedding Policy
  • Most Read
    • Most Read This Week
    • Most Read This Month
    • Most Read This Year
    • Most Read All Time
  • Most Recent
  • More News
    • Crime
    • Ridgeland Crime Map
    • Documents
    • Features
    • Politics
    • Public Notices
    • Videos
  • E-Editions
    • Archives
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine E-Edition
    • Special Section E-Editions
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Polls
    • Submit a Letter
  • Advertising
    • Ad Rates
    • Ad Staff
  • Calendar
  • Comics/Games
    • Cartoons
    • Comics
    • Crossword
    • Lexigo
    • Sudoku
  • Obituaries
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Social
    • Anniversaries/Birthdays
    • Engagements/Weddings
    • Schools
    • Submit an Anniversary
    • Submit a Birthday
    • Submit an Engagement
    • Submit School News
    • Submit a Wedding
  • Subscribe
  • State
    • Most Read - Statewide

Main navigation (mobile)

  • Post
    • Leaderboard
    • Post Dashboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our History
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
    • Wedding Policy
  • Most Read
  • Most Recent
  • More News
  • E-Editions
    • Archives
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine E-Edition
    • Special Section E-Editions
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Polls
    • Submit a Letter
  • Advertising
    • Ad Rates
    • Ad Staff
  • Calendar
  • Comics/Games
  • Obituaries
  • Social
    • Anniversaries/Birthdays
    • Engagements/Weddings
    • Schools
    • Submit an Anniversary
    • Submit a Birthday
    • Submit an Engagement
    • Submit School News
    • Submit a Wedding
  • Subscribe
  • State

Charter schools receive taxpayer dollars. Should their board members follow state ethics laws?

By Kate Royals - Mississippi Today , READ MORE > 15,473 Reads
On Wed, 01/20/2021 - 5:46 PM

The Mississippi Ethics Commission says charter school board members are subject to state ethics laws, which prohibit conflicts of interest that could lead to the misspending of public dollars.

But several operators and advocates of Mississippi charter schools, which receive taxpayer funding, say they should be exempt from those laws.

The conflict was brought to light by Ethics Commission opinions filed in 2020 after two charter schools were discovered to be spending their public funding with board members’ employers.

The revelations highlight long-standing tension between charter school and traditional public school advocates, who say charter schools need to be held to the same standards as other public governing bodies.

“The state ethics laws are not overly burdensome; they simply say that members of state agency governing boards cannot profit off of state funds by directing contracts to their own businesses or employer,” said Nancy Loome, executive director of the public education advocacy group The Parents’ Campaign. “All public school board members must abide by those rules, and charter school board members should, as well.”

Charter schools are, by law, public schools funded by local and state tax dollars. They do not charge students tuition and are held to the same academic and accountability standards as traditional public schools. These schools are often the subject of scrutiny because they are allowed more flexibility than public schools in how they operate. 

Mississippi’s charter school law, adopted by lawmakers in 2013, is the only one in the nation that does not have a specific conflict of interest provision in it, according to the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools.

Charters are required by state law to operate as nonprofit organizations and must adhere to IRS regulations that require conflict of interest disclosures. However, those nonprofit regulations are much less strict than several key ethics laws that public schools are subject to, including the banning all business between the organizations and board members’ companies.

Traditional public schools, meanwhile, are subject to the more stringent state ethics laws, including that school boards cannot do business with individual board members’ companies.

“All we’re saying is members of public charter school boards have to live by the same rules as members of every other type of school board,” Tom Hood, the executive director of the Ethics Commission, told Mississippi Today. “They’re not getting treated any worse or any better.”

The ethics questions arose after Ambition Prep, a K-8 charter school in Jackson, used federal funding in 2018 to contract with an insurance company owned by one of the school’s board members. Ambition Prep officials told Mississippi Today they followed their own conflict of interest laws and were not aware they had to adhere to the state ethics laws.

“Nobody knew or stated (at that time) that charter schools had to follow the ethics laws,” said DeArchie Scott, the school’s founder and executive director.

A separate charter school also attempted to enter into a contract with a board member’s professional development company but stopped at the request of the Mississippi Charter Authorizer Board, the board that oversees charter schools in the state.

The Ethics Commission responded in a 2020 ruling that all of the state’s charter school governing board members are subject to all the restrictions of the state ethics law, just as traditional public school board members, lawmakers and other public officials are.

The commission reasoned that because charter schools receive public dollars and their boards are subject to other laws such as those that require open meetings and the Public Records Act, “members of charter school governing boards are ‘public servants’ as defined (in the law), and are subject to all the applicable provisions of the Ethics in Government Law.” 

Several charter school operators disagreed with both Ethics Commission rulings. 

On Dec. 14, 2020, a lawyer for Ambition Prep wrote a letter to the commission, asking it to reconsider whether charter school board members are subject to state ethics laws. The commission declined.

Members of the charter school community argue the Ethics Commission’s take on their role goes against the intention of the charter school law that was passed in 2013, and that the law does not explicitly state board members are subject to ethics laws. 

Some also say there may be unintended consequences as a result of the opinions. 

Rachel Canter, executive director of Mississippi First Credit: Mississippi First

Rachel Canter, executive director of the nonprofit education group Mississippi First, was involved in the creation of the charter school law prior to its passage in 2013. 

“It’s a big legal shift from the understanding that everybody had about charter schools for the seven years prior to (the Ethics Commission opinions), which was that charter schools are overseen and held accountable, according to the charter school law, in their contract by the authorizer board and not by any other government agency or entity,” Canter said.

She said charter schools have already operated under nonprofit rules — the looser IRS regulations — that aim to prevent conflicts of interest.

“We in the nonprofit world have something called arm’s length negotiation, which says if you’re a board member and something comes before the board in which you have a financial interest, you have to recuse yourself and leave the room,” Canter said. “But if it’s in the best interest of the organization, the decision can still be made (to approve the arrangement).” 

Canter also noted that charter schools’ finances are audited annually by the Charter School Authorizer Board. She said the effect of the opinions is essentially stating to charter schools that they now must operate under a different set of rules. 

“Charter schools are saying you’re trying to make us governmental organizations and we are not government organizations,” she said.

Jon Rybka, the CEO of RePublic Schools, a Nashville-based charter operator with three schools in Jackson, said charter schools are unique and face different challenges than other governmental entities. Rybka pointed out that in Mississippi, charter schools are “both governmental entities and nonprofits” and believes that they should be governed by regulations that are tailored to their unique situations. 

“If I had to guess, every mission-driven school, church or nonprofit has board members that are involved because they care about the mission, so they’re probably involved in the mission in other areas as well,” Rybka said. “I just don’t want to see this ruling getting in the way of good people bringing their resources to the mission.”

Amanda Johnson, Executive Director of Clarksdale Collegiate Charter School. Credit: Staci Lewis

Amanda Johnson, executive director of Clarksdale Collegiate Public Charter School in Clarksdale, said she is concerned about the opinions’ impact on charter schools’ flexibility and autonomy.

“When I think about why I do this work and why I believe in charters, part of it is because they are set up to be different and be provided with some additional flexibility, appropriate flexibility, that allows the schools to operate in a different way than a traditional district,” Johnson said. “It’s not that we are above ethics laws or behaving ethically, but we should not be under the same rules and regulations that a governmental agency would be under.”

Johnson, along with others, also says that restrictions like these are part of the reason charter schools have not expanded in Mississippi as they have in other areas. Since 2013, when the charter school law was passed, only eight charter schools have opened in the state, six of which are in Jackson.

“There are charter schools, CMOs (charter management organizations), that operate in other states that the Authorizer Board has tried to attract, legislators have tried to attract (to Mississippi) and haven’t been able to,” said Johnson. “Making this work more restrictive is going against what charter schools were designed to be. It makes it less attractive (to CMOs) and more difficult (for schools) to recruit board members as well.” 

But others disagree with the sentiments of the state’s charter operators and say it’s important for charter schools to be held to the same standards as traditional public schools.

“There have been many unfortunate stories from other states of charter school laws leading to scandals involving misuse of taxpayer funds,” Loome, with The Parents’ Campaign, said. “Thankfully, Mississippi law protects children and taxpayers from that sort of unscrupulous activity.”

-- Article credit to Kate Royals of Mississippi Today --

‹ PreviousNext ›

Most Recent

Mission Mississippi - March 05, 2021 Livestream

The state-wide livestream for Mission Mississippi - March 05th, 2021

Wicker Rejects Effort to Weaken Election Integrity
Hyde-Smith Announces $6.99 Million Army Contract for UAS Work in Starkville
Treasurer McRae: Don’t Use Mississippi Money to Bailout Poorly Managed States
Commissioner Gipson Announces New Mississippi Agriculture Youth Council
Guest Highlights Effects of Biden Administration Border Decisions

Most Read News Article

  • Week
  • Month
  • Year
  • All Time

Etairos HVAC Merges with Delta Thermal Solutions

A merger of two privately held HVAC manufacturers’ representatives— Etairos HVAC and Delta Thermal… READ MORE

Michael Ramirez - February 28, 2021
Michael Ramirez - February 26, 2021
City of Jackson Announces Vaccination Day on March 6
Jackson Mayor Extends Curfew Order for Minors Younger Than 18
Why teachers in Mississippi work second jobs to get by

Marshall Ramsey: Thank You

Medicaid. -- Cartoon by Marshall Ramsey, Mississippi Today - February 05, 2021 --

Honor Roll: St. Joseph Catholic
Archie Comics - February 07, 2021
Archie Comics - February 14, 2021
Archie Comics - February 21, 2021
License Reciprocity, Teacher Loan Repayment Focus of Two Education Bills Passed by Mississippi Senate

Governor Reeves explains "Safer at Home" policy

On his Facebook post, Gov. Tate Reeves explained that Mississippians are now "encouraged" but not "… READ MORE

Northsider Reed Hogan's over-the-counter Covid-19 treatment cuts death rate 25-40%
One world conspiracy
Ribbon Bullies, McCarthy, and Thinkists
Thanks COVID, now tailgating is canceled
Offers Solution: Northsiders form company to address business needs in time of coronavirus

Governor Reeves explains "Safer at Home" policy

On his Facebook post, Gov. Tate Reeves explained that Mississippians are now "encouraged" but not "… READ MORE

Northsider Reed Hogan's over-the-counter Covid-19 treatment cuts death rate 25-40%
Biggest injustice in college sports
One world conspiracy
Shellye Stanley McCarty
Rich retiring politicians

March 4, 2021

Sign Up for Notifications of Local Breaking News

Start E-mail NotificationsStop E-mail NotificationsStart Mobile NotificationsStop Mobile Notifications

Social

In Cleveland, parents fear the cost of losing pre-K programs

When it became clear that 384 students unenrolled from the public schools here and weren’t coming… READ MORE

Studying forces
Book Buddies
Media impact awards
Honor Roll: Mississippi State University
Most Versatile

Magazine block

Obituaries

Francis Julian Carroll, Jr.

Francis Julian Carroll, Jr. passed away peacefully at home on Wednesday, March 3, 2021. He was born… READ MORE

Dr. Thomas (Tom) George Coleman
Maxine Mable White
Daniel Stephen McNamara
Elizabeth (Betsy) Nelson Craft
Molloy Simpson (M. S.) Bennett

Opinion

Wicker Rejects Effort to Weaken Election Integrity

Below is a political opinion column from Senator Roger Wicker:

Treasurer McRae: Don’t Use Mississippi Money to Bailout Poorly Managed States
Opinion: Tax overhaul unlikely to fly
Opinion: State of the state is looking better
SALTER:China trade standoff resolution is critical for Mississippi farmers seeking vital markets
Opinion: David v. Goliath or greater fool?

Weddings & Engagements

Miss Parker and Fuggett to exchange wedding vows April 17 at Northminster

Mr. and Mrs. Guy M. Parker III announced the engagement of their daughter, Rebecca Blackmon Parker… READ MORE

Fuller and Rozier united in marriage July 24 in outdoor ceremony
Miss Cannon and Simmons to exchange wedding vows April 10 in Jackson
McPherson and Yerger wed November 7
Miss Montagnet and Franklin planning March 27 wedding at Covenant Presbyterian
Liston and Draughn exchange wedding vows October 10 at Fairview

newsworthy jan 7 2021  LIUL   Our Town 2020   What's Hot 2019   Gift Guide 2019    The Look Fall 2019  

Click here to read The Northside Sun Special Sections

COMPANY COMMUNITY ADVERTISE E-EDITIONS MORE NEWS
Contact Community Calendar Subscribe Magazine E-Edition Cartoons
FAQ/Help Obituaries Ad Rates Newspaper Archive Columns
Our History Engagements/Weddings Ad Staff Newspaper E-Edition Comics
Our Staff Most Read My Account Special Section Editorials
Statewide Most Recent Rack Locations   Features

Click on the city name to visit its website.

ACKERMAN  •  CARROLLTON  •  CHARLESTON  •  CLARKSDALE  •  COLUMBIA  •  DUMAS(Ark.)  •  EUPORA  •  FOREST  • 

FRANKLINTON(La.)  • GREENVILLE  •  GREENWOOD  •  GRENADA  •  HATTIESBURG  •  JACKSON  •  KOSCIUSKO  •  INDIANOLA  • 

LOUISVILLE  • MAGEE  • MENDENHALL  •  McCOMB  •  NEWTON  •  PETAL  •  QUITMAN  •  SENATOBIA  •  TALLULAH(La.)  •  WINONA  •  YAZOO CITY


Copyright 2020 - The Northside Sun | Privacy Statement | Help | Terms of Service

The Northside Sun - 246 Briarwood Dr.- Jackson, MS 39206 - (601)-957-1122

Emmerich Newspapers proud to serve your local communities.

Thank you for visiting our website.