Skip to main content

User account menu

  • Log in
  • Rss
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Shopping cart 0
Cart

Search

Search
Home The Northside Sun
  • Post
    • Leaderboard
    • Post Dashboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our History
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
    • Wedding Policy
  • Most Read
    • Most Read This Week
    • Most Read This Month
    • Most Read This Year
    • Most Read All Time
  • Most Recent
  • More News
    • Cartoons
    • Crime
    • Documents
    • Features
    • Politics
    • Public Notices
    • Videos
  • E-Editions
    • Archives
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine E-Edition
    • Special Section E-Editions
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Polls
    • Submit a Letter
  • Advertising
    • Ad Rates
    • Ad Staff
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Social
    • Anniversaries/Birthdays
    • Engagements/Weddings
    • Schools
    • Submit an Anniversary
    • Submit a Birthday
    • Submit an Engagement
    • Submit School News
    • Submit a Wedding
  • Subscribe
  • State

Main navigation (mobile)

  • Post
    • Leaderboard
    • Post Dashboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our History
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
    • Wedding Policy
  • Most Read
  • Most Recent
  • More News
  • E-Editions
    • Archives
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine E-Edition
    • Special Section E-Editions
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Polls
    • Submit a Letter
  • Advertising
    • Ad Rates
    • Ad Staff
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
  • Social
    • Anniversaries/Birthdays
    • Engagements/Weddings
    • Schools
    • Submit an Anniversary
    • Submit a Birthday
    • Submit an Engagement
    • Submit School News
    • Submit a Wedding
  • Subscribe
  • State

Billion dollar flooding lawsuit gets off the ground

By Wyatt Emmerich , READ MORE > 62,616 Reads
On Fri, 02/07/2020 - 10:14 AM

Five hundred Mississippi landowners scored a big victory in Natchez recently in their quest to be reimbursed a billion dollars by the federal government for flooding their land.

The U. S. Army Corps of Engineers was asking federal claims court judge Elaine Kaplan to dismiss the suit. After an hour of hearing both sides, Kaplan ruled that the suit could go forward.

Kaplan made the ruling directly from the bench that day – a most unusual action. Typically, judges wait weeks or months to review the arguments and then issue a written ruling.

Kaplan’s immediate bench ruling bodes well for the ultimate success of the lawsuit. The 100 or so plaintiffs and their attorneys who attended the hearing were almost giddy with excitement.

The Mississippi plaintiffs have some heavy hitters for attorneys. Legendary trial lawyer Don Barrett of Lexington has teamed up with top-notch Washington D.C. firm Cuneo, Gilbert & LaDuca, an expert in takings cases. This is the real deal.

The case is pretty easy to understand. Seventy or so years ago, experts realized the Mississippi River was about to divert from its historical path through Baton Rouge and New Orleans. An alternative route down the Atchafalaya River basin was half as long and twice as steep. Sooner or later, Mother Nature was going to reroute the mighty Mississippi.

The movers and shakers of this country realized that would be a disaster. There was a trillion dollars in ports, oil refineries and infrastructure around the Mississippi River at Baton Rouge and New Orleans. They couldn’t let the river divert.

So Congress authorized the corps to build the Old River Control Structure 35 miles south of Natchez in 1963 and the Morganza floodgates 25 miles south of that. It was a marvelous engineering feat. It works by diverting 70 percent of the Mississippi to New Orleans and only 30 percent down the Atchafalaya River.

Only one problem. By channeling and controlling the river, the silt inevitably built up on the river bottom, raising the water levels of the river. The water had to go somewhere. It went into Mississippi, flooding 500,000 acres. Over time, the flooding has gotten worse. A flood that might happen once every 15 years is happening every year, destroying the usefulness of the land for farming, ranching, drilling or hunting.

As Jonathan Cuneo told the judge: “Congress and the corps didn’t do anything wrong. But the public should bear the cost.”

In other words, the Congress’ attempts to save a trillion dollars of infrastructure at an engineering cost of $14 billion made perfect sense. And it made perfect sense to implement a plan that would eventually cause upriver flooding. That land was one-thousandth of the value of the ports and refineries.

That’s not the point. The point is that the Mississippi landowners should not have to bear the cost of having their land flooded for the public good. The feds need to compensate them for what they have done to their land.

This is a classic takings case. The Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution forbids the federal government from taking someone’s property for a public good without fairly compensating them. As a result, there is an entirely separate federal claims court system to hear these cases. The case law is well established and the Mississippi landowners have a great deal of legal precedent on their side.

Mississippi, through the Secretary of State’s office, has joined this lawsuit as the main plaintiff. Former Secretary of State Delbert Hoseman saw how the state was losing tens of millions of dollars because 16th Section land, designated for funding schools, were rendered unproductive.

The new Mississippi Secretary of State, Michael Watson, was at the trial. Sitting in the audience were dozens of local school officials who have seen their 16th Section land money decline dramatically. From the plaintiffs perspective, this probably created some politically positive trial visuals for the Obama-appointed judge.

This lawsuit is just the start. There are other lawsuits representing other distinct groups harmed by the flooding.

Perhaps the greatest damage is being done to the Mississippi Sound, where the crab, oyster and fish industries are being strangled by salinity changes and algae blooms caused by the opening of the Bonnet Carre discharge gates on Lake Pontchartrain. Those damages could be in the billions.

Since it was built after the disastrous 1929 flood, the Bonnet Carre has been opened 14 times. Four of those times came in the last four years.

Then there are landowners in the Yazoo drainage basin who are seeing a huge increase in flooding frequency and severity. The Yazoo basin flows into the Mississippi basin. But when the river is high, these close the gates at Steele Bayou just north of Vicksburg, which makes the Yazoo basin flooding worse.

At the trial, I talked to multiple landowners, big and small. They all told the same story of steady increases in the frequency and severity of the floods until their land became useless.

The corps will argue this is caused by increased rains and global warming. There is a slight increase in precipitation, but not nearly enough to cause the flooding. This will be a battle of expert witnesses. The corps will find it difficult to show that Mississippi isn’t an innocent casualty in its effort to save Baton Rouge and New Orleans.

The corps could immediately alleviate the Mississippi floods by sending more water down the Atchafalaya using the Old River Control Structure. This is where politics gets involved. Mississippi’s influence in Congress isn’t what it once was. Such a policy change would flood a lot of development that has slowly increased in the Atchafalaya floodway and around Morgan City.

Or, worst of all, Mother Nature may trump all the legal wrangling. The Mississippi River is long overdue for a major course change, which has happened over the centuries with amazing regularity. Such levee break could kill thousands and turn the Atchafalaya River into the lower Mississippi River. 

That would permanently solve Mississippi’s flooding problem. But the cost to the nation would be immense.

‹ PreviousNext ›

Social

Christmas gifts

First Presbyterian Day School students, faculty, and staff partnered with God’s Haven, a ministry… READ MORE

Green’s latest book tells story of German girl finding joy despite adversities of WWII
Girls cross country
Faith for Finn
Mr. and Miss St. Andrew’s
Super Hair

January14, 2021

Obituaries

Helen Ricks Rogers

Lt. Colonel Jacob Lenier Bland
Bobbie Lou Wilson Mayo
Carolyn Maxwell Perry
Jane Robinson Emidy Magee
Jean Turner Brewer

Most Recent

Wicker Hails $2.377 Million Award for UMMC Connected Care Pilot Program

U.S.

Health department clarifies vaccine supply, new appointments available Jan. 25
Congressman Guest Applauds Army Corp of Engineers’ Record of Decision
Justin Moore Announced as Entertainment for February 16 Dixie National Rodeo Performance
Wicker Praises Army Corps Decision on Yazoo Backwater Pumps Project
Governor Tate Reeves Extends Executive Order

Most Read News Article

  • Week
  • Month
  • Year
  • All Time

Prep, JA, First Pres and St. Andrew's close for Monday, Jan. 11

Jackson Academy and Jackson Prep will be closed Monday, January 11, due to weather and hazardous… READ MORE

OPINION: Attack on capitol fueled by Internet conspiracy theories
Wicker Hails $2.377 Million Award for UMMC Connected Care Pilot Program
Mississippi Economic Council's Virtual Capital Day 2021 Draws Over 500 Leaders on Livestream
Editorial: Demonstrations must be peaceful
DPS Most Wanted list proves successful with multiple captures in under a week

Indianola Doctor Who Suffered Effects of COVID Among the First to Get Vaccine at Clinic

When Dr. Eddie Donahoe heard that a COVID-19 vaccine was on the way and had the potential to be… READ MORE

Gov. William Winter dies
Opinion: Madison jail beating death must be resolved
Miss Baker and Mundine planning January 30 wedding at St. Matthew’s Methodist
Jackson revelers block I-55
Governor Tate Reeves Makes Statement on COVID-19 Vaccine

Northsider Reed Hogan's over-the-counter Covid-19 treatment cuts death rate 25-40%

COVID-19 Treatment Success with a Combination of Two Over-the-Counter Drugs -- Pepcid and Zyrtec  … READ MORE

Governor Reeves explains "Safer at Home" policy
One world conspiracy
Billion dollar flooding lawsuit gets off the ground
Ribbon Bullies, McCarthy, and Thinkists
Thanks COVID, now tailgating is canceled

Northsider Reed Hogan's over-the-counter Covid-19 treatment cuts death rate 25-40%

COVID-19 Treatment Success with a Combination of Two Over-the-Counter Drugs -- Pepcid and Zyrtec  … READ MORE

Biggest injustice in college sports
Governor Reeves explains "Safer at Home" policy
Shellye Stanley McCarty
One world conspiracy
Rich retiring politicians

Sign Up for Notifications of Local Breaking News

Start E-mail NotificationsStop E-mail NotificationsStart Mobile NotificationsStop Mobile Notifications

Opinion

Wicker: Big Tech Has Crossed a Red Line

OPINION column - Senator Roger Wicker Wave of Censorship Confirms Need to Confront Tech Monopolies

Opinion: It’s official: Georgia is now a purple state
Outdoors in the Sun: Yellowstone Park - A national treasure
Opinion: Initiative lawsuit faces hurdles
Life's a Garden: Raining seed catalogs
Opinion: Law enforcement must stop hooligans from abusing I-55

Weddings & Engagements

Miss Gathings and Allen planning February 20 wedding at Galloway Methodist

Mr. and Mrs. Robert Milton Gathings Jr. of Jackson announce the engagement of their daughter, Toy… READ MORE

Miss Farrington, Thompson planning February 26 wedding in Florida
Churchill and Carpenter exchange wedding vows Sept. 12 in outside service
Banks and Carroll united in marriage August 1 at St. Luke’s Methodist
Miss Ethridge and Dale making plans to wed December 30 in Greensboro
Miss Baker and Mundine planning January 30 wedding at St. Matthew’s Methodist

Magazine block

Special SectionsLIUL

Archive block

newsworthy jan 7 2021  LIUL   Our Town 2020   What's Hot 2019   Gift Guide 2019    The Look Fall 2019  

Click here to read The Northside Sun Special Sections

Copyright 2020 • The Northside Sun
246 Briarwood Dr. • Jackson, MS 39206 •
(601)-957-1122

Emmerich Newspapers proudly serve the following Mississippi communities:

Click on the city name to visit its website.

ACKERMAN • CARROLLTON • CHARLESTON • CLARKSDALE • COLUMBIA • EUPORA • FOREST • GREENVILLE • GREENWOOD • GRENADA • HATTIESBURG • JACKSON • KOSCIUSKO • INDIANOLA • LOUISVILLE • MAGEE • MENDENHALL • McCOMB • NEWTON • PETAL • QUITMAN • SENATOBIA • WINONA • YAZOO CITY

As well as: DUMAS, Ark. • TALLULAH, La • FRANKLINTON, La.

For more information on how to extend your advertising message to these communities, click here.